Testimonials
Kaitlin edited my novel, Treading Water. I don't think I've ever met—let alone worked with—an editor as fast, thorough, and fantastic as her. Not only that, but she was truly my biggest cheerleader during the whole process. Throughout her edits she told me what she loved in addition to what needed work. This kind of balance and support was exactly what I needed to feel confident in sending my novel to the query trenches. I subsequently signed with my agent four months after I got Kaitlin's edits. I am sincerely convinced I got my agent because of Kaitlin's input and skill. Thank you, Kaitlin!
—Emily Smiley, Author of Treading Water
The full Kaitlin Schmidt editorial experience is unparalleled. She's a champion for my book and an editor who so intuitively understands my brain, writing intention, and style. She is always down to gush over line-level prose and is always in my corner. My writing shines brighter and is so much stronger because of the care, support, and enthusiasm that Kaitlin brings to my words and story. She loves to get deep into details as much as I do too, which is an added bonus, and a very fun part of the process!
—Sri Savita, Romance & Erotica Author; Author of The Deed with the Duke
When I started working with Kaitlin, I had never written a novel before and did not know what to expect from the editing process. She guided me through it so graciously and never left me hanging with a question. Her editing notes were detailed and extensive and written in a way that didn't make me feel overwhelmed. Shortly after I made the edits she suggested, I sent my work out and got an offer on my manuscript, and I am now in the process of traditionally publishing my book. I got many compliments from my new agent and editor about how "polished" the manuscript was. I have no doubt a big reason I am publishing today is because of her work on my book.
—Inez Ray, Author of Buzzard (forthcoming publication in fall 2026 through Bindery Books)
Working with Kaitlin was amazing! Not only is she incredibly thorough, but she is extremely organized, patient, and knowledgable about how a book should be put together. She took my manuscript, which had already been through two professional edits before it got to her, and still found a ton of typos, saving me time, credibility, and money in the long run. Now I’ll know to go with her the first time around! Can’t recommend her services enough!
—Michelle Cox, Award-Winning Author of the Henrietta and Inspector Howard series and Matched in Merriweather
I initially worked with Kaitlin in a team which produced short stories. As an online colleague, I found her encouraging, supportive, insightful, and always generous with her time and expertise. It was, therefore, a “no brainer” to approach Kaitlin for help in developing a story I had written as a serial into a manuscript for a novel. Her approach was professional, friendly, supportive, and flexible. I’m a complete newbie and needed someone who had my back and gave me guidance, and Kaitlin was the whole package—providing developmental ideas, story arc improvements, grammar advice of course—but most of all, she “gets” my vision and wants the best for it. She’s so much more than I expected. My recommendation of her services is wholehearted, and from the glowing feedback from others, it's clear I am not alone in thinking she’s a treasure.
—Jacinta Palmer, Author at Fiction Without Frontiers
Working with Kaitlin was a wonderful experience! As a writer that tends to craft manuscripts on the shorter side, the insightful feedback she provided helped me deep dive into my story in ways I had yet to do before. As a result, my writing has definitely improved, and now I have a full length manuscript instead of a novella! This was my first time reaching out to an editor, and I would not hesitate to work with Kaitlin again in the future.
—Ashleigh Martin, Author at www.AshleighMartin.com
Kaitlin was the editor of my first novella. Prior to that, I had only written short stories, which frankly were the extent of my limited writing skills. She patiently helped me refine my techniques and process while walking alongside, and was always nurturing while letting me choose the path my tale took. The end product is marvelous, but what mattered just as much was the confidence I gained to write a second, with two more in the works. I would have never taken this leap without her, and for that I am forever grateful.
—Ramone Quides, Author at www.ramonequides.com and of A Second Chance at Submission at theoreads.com
Working with Kaitlin on Hikeological Escape was one of the smartest decisions I made in the entire publishing process. Her attention to detail is nothing short of surgical. She caught inconsistencies, timeline hiccups, formatting quirks, and typos that had slipped past me on previous rounds of editing. The result was a book I could be proud to put into the world. She’s not just thorough—she’s relentless. Organized, sharp-eyed, and honest without ever being harsh, she brought clarity, rhythm, and flow to the manuscript while respecting my voice. I can’t recommend her highly enough.
—Chris Homan, author of Hikeological Escape
Kaitlin is always quick to respond, deeply intuitive and understanding about the core of the writing process, and delivers more than I expect. I would always recommend her to anyone looking for help developing their story at any point along the way.
—David Beaumier, Author and Editor at The Dancer Writes and Marketing and Communications Manager at Chanticleer Book Reviews
As a traditionally published author and ghostwriter with nearly twenty books under my belt, I’ve worked with many different editors, but Kaitlin blew me away. She’s incredibly thorough and does her research. More importantly, she intuitively understood my intent, so her edits consistently improved my writing without changing it.
—Josh Kelley, Freelance Writer at www.joshkelley.ink
It’s been a privilege to have Kaitlin Schmidt edit my work. Whether reading line-by-line, assessing character motivation, pacing, or considering the big-picture narrative arc, Kaitlin reads with a critical eye, providing thorough, considerate feedback aimed at helping the writer achieve the aims of both story and writer. The result is that of a polished, publishable piece.
—Randall Dills, Author of The Universe at the Point of Contraction
When I received my first line editing pass from Kaitlin, my response was, “Wow!” What struck me was the detail, the care, and the comments which all proved she understood what I was attempting to convey. She took my concept descriptions and fine-tuned them with a meticulous touch, suggesting the perfect words. It is clear Kaitlin has a natural talent to help you elevate your written ideas to their most polished form.
—Dr. J. | Donna Jennings, Ph.D., Author of The Fiction Writer’s Sexuality Guide
I was so lucky to be involved in the Cards of Passion book series with Kaitlin. Her beta reading of my initial manuscript gave me fantastic ideas, reinforced changes I’d contemplated, and encouraged me to slash sections with abandon and write new chapters. As this is my first published work, her input was invaluable. I regret waiting too long to try to book her editing services, but eagerly look forward to working with Kaitlin again in the future.
—Henrietta Holland, Author of Wild Within
If you’re looking for an editor that goes above and beyond to understand the scope and direction of your work and helps take it to new heights, look no further than Kaitlin Schmidt. She understood what I wanted from my story, offered amazing suggestions on where to change the narrative, and helped to pinpoint plot holes that needed strengthening. She gave me ideas that really polished it and gave it a more solid footing.
What really sets Kaitlin apart is her passion for the writing and storytelling. Her meticulous attention to detail enhances the story and ensures that every word is necessary to move my story forward.
Working with Kaitlin has been a wonderful experience. She presents her knowledge in a constructive, positive way that gets her point across while keeping you from getting discouraged. Kaitlin's impeccable skills have elevated my work to a new level, and I wouldn't hesitate to suggest her to anyone working on a project that needs a helping hand. I look forward to continuing to work with her on my future projects.
—Angel Wolfe, Author at www.angelwolfenovels.com
Kaitlin was an amazing employee during her time on the copyediting staff at The Spokesman-Review. Her positive and friendly personality made her a joy to work with and allowed her to quickly become a popular addition to our staff. She was always willing to go above and beyond for our company and had an incredible eye for detail. Kaitlin was a great communicator who could always be counted on to share her ideas and thoughts with her colleagues. She quickly earned the respect of the veteran journalists whose writing she helped improve, and she was an extremely valuable asset to our team. We were so lucky to have had Kaitlin on board!
—Rick House, Former News and National Editor at The Spokesman-Review
Working with Kaitlin has been an absolute gift. I'm new to the writing industry, and upon having her review my first portion of work, I was incredibly nervous and hesitant. I was pleasantly surprised with the entire process. She immediately seemed to understand my vision, asked clarifying questions, and provided constructive criticism in a way that was empathetic, kind, and a true benefit to my writing. Writing often involves writing a piece of ourselves into our exposition, and it's no small thing to have another person review those deep parts of yourself. The session I had with her helped inspire me to finish my manuscript! She is truly a wonderful person to have on your editorial team.
—Hannah Rodgers, Author
Kaitlin’s insight as an editor was an invaluable tool when I struggled with a character’s development. She asks questions that focus on the deeper story, character motivations, hidden symbolism, or connections. Her editorial style is positive, thoughtful, and designed to help the writer tell their story in their voice, but with better punctuation (at least in my case). Working with Kaitlin has made me a better writer and I could not recommend her more highly.
—Patricia Richardson, Author
Kaitlin Schmidt gave the bold, honest feedback I craved as an author. Her uncanny insight into character motivations helped me work through incongruities in my work. Her critiques proved well thought-out and concise.
—Karl Mariotti, Author